Comments on: Why Carly Smithson Finally Lost On American Idol http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/ Pop Culture Mashed Up And Tasty Fri, 29 Aug 2008 06:45:00 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.5.1 By: carly smithson american idol trackback uri closed http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/#comment-1260 carly smithson american idol trackback uri closed Tue, 13 May 2008 00:37:03 +0000 http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/#comment-1260 [...] carly smithson Booted?? ... Close. Social Web E-mail. del.icio.us Digg Furl Netscape Yahoo! ...http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/The World of Scott MindeauxTHIS is american Idol! We are down to the Top 8 and the ... carly [...] [...] carly smithson Booted?? … Close. Social Web E-mail. del.icio.us Digg Furl Netscape Yahoo! …http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/The World of Scott MindeauxTHIS is american Idol! We are down to the Top 8 and the … carly [...]

]]> By: Cheryl http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/#comment-1218 Cheryl Thu, 24 Apr 2008 19:00:28 +0000 http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/#comment-1218 Rock on Taylor - we love ya! Rock on Taylor - we love ya!

]]> By: Dave http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/#comment-1217 Dave Thu, 24 Apr 2008 16:25:11 +0000 http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/#comment-1217 Okay, although I wouldn't put it just like you did, your theory was the very one I predicted on Tuesday night to my wife. You're right- you can't get on "American Idol" all tatted up and sing a song like "Jesus Christ Superstar" to a conservative audience and get away with it. I predicted that she would be booted for that very reason, and I think "our' theory is correct. I could almost hear the horrified parents across the country yelling to their little kids, "PUT THAT PHONE DOWN." Okay, although I wouldn’t put it just like you did, your theory was the very one I predicted on Tuesday night to my wife. You’re right- you can’t get on “American Idol” all tatted up and sing a song like “Jesus Christ Superstar” to a conservative audience and get away with it. I predicted that she would be booted for that very reason, and I think “our’ theory is correct. I could almost hear the horrified parents across the country yelling to their little kids, “PUT THAT PHONE DOWN.”

]]> By: Themeless Randoms http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/#comment-1216 Themeless Randoms Thu, 24 Apr 2008 15:41:04 +0000 http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/#comment-1216 <strong>American Idol: Carly Smithson Booted...</strong> Ok I admit it, the girlfriend and I are huge fans of American Idol. I never thought that I’d get into a show like this because I’ve always had the “if there isn’t guitar, I’m not listening” mentality, but this season... American Idol: Carly Smithson Booted…

Ok I admit it, the girlfriend and I are huge fans of American Idol. I never thought that I’d get into a show like this because I’ve always had the “if there isn’t guitar, I’m not listening” mentality, but this season…

]]> By: American Idol » Why Carly Smithson Finally Lost On American Idol http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/#comment-1215 American Idol » Why Carly Smithson Finally Lost On American Idol Thu, 24 Apr 2008 15:17:17 +0000 http://refriedscreens.com/american-idol/why-carly-smithson-finally-lost-on-american-idol/#comment-1215 [...] refrieds wrote an interesting post today on Why Carly Smithson Finally Lost On American IdolHere’s a quick excerptAmerican Idol viewers are abuzz with confusion over why Syesha Mercado and Carly Smithson were in the bottom two. According to this site, the first performer of the evening is most likely to lose. According THIS site, it’s all the fault … [...] [...] refrieds wrote an interesting post today on Why Carly Smithson Finally Lost On American IdolHere’s a quick excerptAmerican Idol viewers are abuzz with confusion over why Syesha Mercado and Carly Smithson were in the bottom two. According to this site, the first performer of the evening is most likely to lose. According THIS site, it’s all the fault … [...]

]]>